Topic:
SELF DEFENSE; CRIMINAL LAW; LEGISLATION;
Location:
CRIMINAL LAW;
Scope:
Court Cases; Connecticut laws/regulations;

OLR Research Report


March 19, 1999

 

99-R-0380

CRIMINAL RULES ON SELF-DEFENSE IN OTHER STATES

 
 

By: Lawrence K. Furbish, Assistant Director

You asked what the criminal rules are concerning the burden of proof for self-defense in selected other states. Your question arises from consideration of HB 6720, An Act Concerning Self-Defense, which would make self-defense an affirmative defense, thus requiring the defendant to establish it by a preponderance of the evidence.

SUMMARY

The states are split in their court cases regarding the burden of proof with some placing it on the defendant and others on the prosecution once the defendant has raised the issue. There is also some disagreement among secondary authorities concerning states' practices concerning this issue. Some sources indicate that the majority of states make self-defense an affirmative defense while others note that in a great majority of states, once self-defense has been raised by the defendant, the state must prove that the defendant did not act in self-defense. Still other commentators have concluded that these differences may be more “verbal” than real.

There also appears to be disagreement concerning the constitutionality of shifting the burden of proof. In Mullaney v. Wilbur (421 U.S. 684 (1975)) the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that it is unconstitutional under due process to shift the burden of proof and require a defendant to prove that he acted in the heat of passion and thus was guilty of manslaughter rather than murder. But the Court also ruled in an Ohio case that it is constitutional for a state to make self-defense an affirmative defense.

CONNECTICUT LAW AND HB 6720

When Connecticut enacted its penal code in 1969 the existing common law rules concerning self-defense were adopted in the code. (Enclosed is OLR report 95-R-1157, which provides historical information on self-defense under Connecticut law.) Regarding defenses generally, CGS § 53a-12 gives the state the burden of disproving any defense, other than an affirmative defense, beyond a reasonable doubt. When an affirmative defense is raised, the defendant must establish it by a preponderance of the evidence, which is a lower standard than beyond a reasonable doubt. Under CGS § 53a-16 “justification” is a defense, but not an affirmative defense. Justification refers to a situation where the accused person's conduct is not considered criminal, and it includes self-defense.

Under the Judicial Branch's “instructions” for judges preparing charges to a jury, justification is the legal term for self-defense, which in turn is the way the law justifies the use of force that would otherwise be illegal (§ 2.40A). The defendant does not have to prove that he acted in self-defense, but once the issue has been raised in the trial, whether by the defense or the prosecution, the state must disprove the defense beyond a reasonable doubt (§ 2.40). In State v. Lewis (220 Conn. 602 (1991)) the Connecticut Supreme Court stated that before a jury instruction on self-defense is warranted, the defendant “bears the initial burden of producing sufficient evidence to inject self-defense into the case” and it must be “sufficient to raise a reasonable doubt in the mind of a rational juror as to whether the defendant acted in self-defense.” Only after the issue has been sufficiently raised, does the state have the burden of disproving it.

Under HB 6720 justification becomes an affirmative defense in certain murder or manslaughter prosecutions if the defendant employed deadly force and in doing so used a firearm he was not eligible to possess. The specific crimes to which the bill applies are murder, capital felony, felony murder, and first and second-degree manslaughter both with and without a firearm.

THE TRADITIONAL COMMON LAW RULE

Most commentators consider the traditional or common law rule to be that in a homicide prosecution, once self-defense is alleged, the defendant has the burden of proving that he acted in self-defense (43 ALR3d 221 p. 224). The degree of proof required varies by jurisdiction and ranges from preponderance to convincing. ALR cites court decisions from the following states as following this rule: Arkansas, Delaware, Georgia, Idaho, Kentucky, Maryland, Nevada, North Carolina, Ohio, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, South Carolina, Tennessee, Texas, Washington, and West Virginia.

In Martin v. Ohio (107 S.Ct. 1098 (1987)) the U.S. Supreme Court noted that the common law rule was that affirmative defenses, including self-defense, were matters for the defendant to prove. According to the Court this was the rule when the Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments to the Constitution were adopted, and it continued to be followed by many states well into the 20th century.

NONTRADITIONAL RULE

It appears that courts have held in an increasing number of states that when self-defense is alleged (1) the defendant must produce enough evidence to raise a reasonable doubt of his guilt or (2) the state must prove that he did not act in self-defense. Commentators term these two formulations “converse ways of stating essentially the same rule” because (1) if the defendant has raised reasonable doubts, the state has not proved its case beyond a reasonable doubt and (2) if the state has proved its case beyond a reasonable doubt, the defendant has not raised reasonable doubt (943 ALR3d 221 p. 224).

ALR list the following states as having court decisions following these two rules. Courts have ruled that the defendant must produce evidence in Alabama, Arizona, California, Colorado, Florida, Illinois, Maine, Mississippi, Missouri, Montana, New Jersey, New Mexico, New York, North Dakota, Oklahoma, South Dakota, and Virginia. Courts have ruled that the state has the burden of proof in Indiana, Iowa, Louisiana, Michigan, Minnesota, Nebraska, New Jersey, and Vermont. The same court case is cited in New Jersey for both propositions, but since there are so closely related, as described above, this does not appear to be a conflict.

Am Jur states that “the great majority of states now apply the rule that, when the issue of self-defense is raised by the defendant or by the evidence presented by the prosecution, the state bears the burden of proving that the defendant did not act in self-defense” (40A Am Jur 2d § 239). In Martin v. Ohio the U.S. Supreme Court states that it is “aware that all but two of the States, Ohio and South Carolina, have abandoned the common-law rule and require the prosecution to prove the absence of self-defense when it is properly raised by the defendant” (Martin p. 1103).

LKF:lc