|
OLR RESEARCH REPORT |
December 24, 1998 |
98-R-1466 | ||
RECENT MASS TRANSIT PROPOSALS INCLUDING THE NEW BRITAIN-HARTFORD BUSWAY |
|||
By: James J. Fazzalaro, Principal Analyst | |||
You asked for general information describing any significant mass transit proposals that have been under discussion in recent years. You wanted specific information on the very recent proposal to build an exclusive "busway" between New Britain and Hartford.
SUMMARY
We have not included every mass transit related idea and legislative proposal that has been offered over the last several years. We are providing general information on several significant proposals and concepts that have been advanced since 1990. One of these, the Shore Line East rail commuter service has been implemented. Several other as yet unimplemented concepts or proposals are also described including: 1991 feasibility studies of rail commuter service in three Hartford area rail corridors (Hartford-Enfield, Hartford-Waterbury, and Eastern Connecticut); a 1994 feasibility analysis of New Haven-Hartford commuter service; the Griffin Line light rail proposal; discussions of the possibility of providing rail service in eastern and southeastern Connecticut; and the Hartford-New Britain Busway proposal.
SIGNIFICANT TRANSIT PROPOSALS
Shore Line East Rail Commuter Service
The Shore Line East rail commuter service operates between New London and New Haven. Service began on May 29, 1990 and ran free of charge for one month. Revenue service began in July 1990. At first, the service ran only between Old Saybrook and New Haven, but was extended to New London in 1996. The Shore Line East service predecessor, though not a direct one, was Amtrak's "Clamdigger" service. It was discontinued in 1971, but reinstituting some type of service was under consideration by the Department of Transportation (DOT) for several years, including a 1986 feasibility study. Additional support for a new service came when then governor William O'Neill began serving as chairman of the National Governor's Association's transportation subcommittee. The Rowland Administration proposed discontinuing the Shore Line East service, but it remains in operation.
Hartford Rail Commuter Corridors
Continuing legislative interest in the subject of commuter rail service led to passage of Special Act 91-20. It required DOT to do feasibility studies on providing commuter rail services in Eastern Connecticut and between Hartford and Enfield, and Hartford and Waterbury. The reports were submitted to the legislature in January, April, and May 1992 respectively. The eastern Connecticut service study included examination of the service potential in five rail corridors including Hartford to Willimantic, Willimantic to New London, Old Saybrook to New London (as an extension to Shore Line East operations), Willimantic to Plainfield, and Groton to Plainfield. The feasibility studies examine possible capital and operating needs and costs, projected ridership, implementation schedules, and other related issues. DOT concluded that Waterbury-Hartford commuter rail service was a "feasible transportation alternative for possible future implementation" but partial implementation between Bristol and Hartford should come first. Capital costs for Bristol-Hartford service were estimated at $66.4 million and annual operating deficits at $5.2 million. DOT did not recommend implementation of any other services in the studies.
Hartford-New Haven Rail Commuter Service
The legislature also expressed an interest in examining the possibility of starting commuter service between New Haven and Hartford. In 1993, several New Haven area legislators asked DOT to look at the feasibility of beginning such service. DOT provided a feasibility analysis to the Transportation Committee in May 1994. DOT's evaluation identified a potential for such service and suggested a two-year service demonstration would be appropriate provided the additional capital and operating funding necessary was made available by the legislature. Although legislation has been submitted at least twice since the report, no funding has been made available to implement it.
The Griffin Line Light Rail Project
The Griffin Line, an abandoned freight rail line connecting Union Station in Hartford and Bloomfield has been the subject of considerable attention for more than 20 years, since a mid-1970s proposal to run buses specially equipped to operate on both rails and road. In its 1991 Connecticut Statewide Transit System Plan, DOT identified the Griffin line as one of two possible "transitways" in the Hartford area. The other was the rail corridor between Cromwell and Hartford. DOT believed the Griffin line transitway could ultimately link the Hartford central business district with Bradley International Airport. Service in these transitways might involve either buses or light rail vehicles. DOT concluded that deciding which type of service would be more feasible would require further analysis.
The Greater Hartford Transit District, the Capitol Region Council of Governments, and significant sectors of the Hartford business community embraced the idea of light rail service in the Griffin line corridor. Considerable effort was made to advance the idea through, among other things, a feasibility analysis and a federally-required major investment study. Partial funding for preliminary engineering and the environmental impact statement for the proposed project was secured through a Congressional appropriation. But DOT opposed advancement of the light rail proposal ahead of other regional needs it considered of higher priority. DOT indicated it would not support inclusion of the Griffin Line project in the region's long-range transportation plan, a necessary prerequisite to receipt of federal funding for the project. Largely as a result of DOT's opposition, further work on the proposal has generally been suspended.
The recently enacted multi-year federal transportation funding authorization legislation, known as the Transportation Equity Act for the 21st Century (TEA-21) provides a special $33 million authorization for a Hartford area fixed guideway system (apparently intended as a monorail type system), but this is for connecting Hartford's North Meadows area with the downtown and not for the Griffin Line. This project is in its initial stages.
Recent Rail Service Proposals in Eastern Connecticut
The extensive economic development going on in eastern Connecticut, brought on in large part by the Mashantucket and Mohegan tribal casinos and their related development initiatives has stimulated several new mass transit-related proposals, but no detailed ideas appear to have emerged yet. The Mashantuckets have discussed a possible project that would involve a monorail type system between their reservation and the New London area. Public officials from the Norwich area, including state legislators, have advanced the idea of instituting commuter rail service on an existing freight line running between Norwich and Worcester, Massachusetts. While these proposals are generating some regional interest, we have little specific information on what is under consideration.
The Hartford-New Britain Busway
DOT has recently proposed a package of transportation improvements for the Hartford-New Britain transportation corridor as part of its Hartford West Major Investment Study. The major investment study is a required step in the process of identifying and advancing transportation improvements seeking federal funding. The proposed busway would link Union Station in Hartford with downtown New Britain. It is intended to operate on or next to the rail right-of-way that currently exists in the corridor.
A total of 13 stations are being proposed with connecting bus routes and van services to take passengers to off-line destinations. Currently proposed station locations include Union Station, the State Armory, the Aetna complex, Park Street, and New Park Avenue in Hartford; Oakwood Avenue and Elmwood in West Hartford; Willard Avenue and Cedar Street in Newington; and East Street, East Main Street and downtown New Britain. Besides serving several of the communities and activity centers along the corridor and the business and government centers at each end, the busway is intended to serve the future business center anticipated to develop at the junction of Routes 9 and 175 in the vicinity of Central Connecticut State University.
Preliminary estimates are approximately $75 million for construction costs and about $20 million in annual operating costs. The busway is being proposed as a less expensive alternative to rail service on the same corridor, which DOT estimates would cost $100-150 million for construction and $22.3 million annually to operate.
JJF:tjo