July 25, 2008 |
2008-R-0424 | |
PROBATE COURT—INDIGENT PEOPLE | ||
| ||
By: George Coppolo, Chief Attorney |
You asked (1) when the probate courts became responsible for the costs of their indigent clients, (2) how this change occurred, (3) what entity paid those costs before the change, and (4) is there any statute or regulation for the probate courts to be self-funding.
SUMMARY
The legislature passed laws in 1989 and 1990 that made probate courts, through the Probate Court Administration Fund, instead of appropriations from the General Fund, the source of funding for counsel fees, filing fees, and other costs associated with indigents who appear in probate court. Before these laws were enacted, indigent costs in probate court were paid for primarily from General Fund appropriations to the Judicial Branch. The law requires probate courts to waive the fees and costs of indigent persons who appear in probate court (CGS § 45-111).
The legislature appears to have made this change to deal with significant budget problems the state was facing. These laws require that indigent costs be paid from the Probate Court Administration Fund, which is funded by assessments made on each probate court. The individual probate courts generate their funds by the fees they charge people who use them.
In 1996 the legislature amended the law to make the Judicial Department responsible for indigent costs, but only if, and only to the extent the legislature appropriated money from the General Fund to the Judicial Branch for this purpose.
The law requires that the probate courts, including salaries, supplies, health insurance, and indigent expenses be funded by fees it collects for the various services it provides (CGS §§ 45a-74 to 45a-84). If there is insufficient money in the Probate Court Administration Fund to pay for the operation of the probate courts, funds must be transferred from the General Fund. This money must be paid back to the General Fund when the Probate Court Administration Fund shows a surplus. Thus far, no money has been transferred to the Probate Court Administration Fund under this provision (CGS § 45a-83).
Since FY89/90 funding for indigent costs in probate courts has come from the Probate Court Administration Fund except for four consecutive fiscal years beginning in FY98/99 and in FY 05/06 in which a portion of the costs came from the judicial department' s budget. Table 3 below shows the amount of indigent funds paid from the Judicial Branch (General Fund) and the Probate Court Administration Fund from FY 78/79 through FY 06/07. This information was compiled by Vinnie Russo, Legislative Liaison for the Office of the Probate Court Administrator.
1989 LEGISLATION
Following in Table 1 is a summary of the legislative changes made in 1989 by PA 89-326 involving a shift from the General Fund to the Probate Court Administration Fund as the source of funds for indigent costs in the probate courts.
Table 1: Changes Made by PA 89-326
PA Section |
Statute |
Probate Court Proceeding |
Indigent Costs |
Old law |
PA 89-326 |
§ 2 |
CGS § 17-178(b) |
Commitment of mentally ill person |
counsel for respondent |
Funds appropriated to the Judicial Dept. |
Probate Court Administration Fund |
Table 1: -Continued-
PA Section |
Statute |
Probate Court Proceeding |
Indigent Costs |
Old law |
PA 89-326 |
§ 3 |
17-178(g) |
Annual psychiatric review and judicial review of involuntarily committed mental patient (costs of doctor appointed to review patient continue to be paid by funds appropriated to the Department of Public Health (DPH) with rates that dept. establishes.) |
All costs and expenses, including entry fees |
Funds appropriated to the Judicial Dept. |
Probate Court Administration Fund (rates established by probate court administrator Instead of Judicial Dept. |
§ 4 |
17-192 |
Application for the release of mentally ill patient from hospital- |
All expenses |
All application expenses paid by the Department of Mental Health (DMH) from appropriated funds according to rates it establishes |
Same as above |
§ 4 |
17-192 |
Application for the release of mentally ill patient from hospital |
Attorneys fees |
Funds appropriated to Judicial Dept. Rates by Jud. Dept. |
Same as above |
§5 |
17-205d |
Application. for commitment of mentally ill child |
Attorney for the parents and child |
Same as above |
Same as above |
§ 6 |
19a-448 |
Involuntary placement with the Department of Mental Retardation (DMR) |
Independent evaluation by psychologist and attorney for respondents |
Same as above |
Same as above |
1990 LEGISLATION
Following in Table 2 is a summary of the legislative changes made in 1990 by PA 90-31 involving a shift from the General Fund to the Probate Court Administration Fund of the responsibility of paying the fees and costs for indigent people.
Table 2: Changes Made by PA 90-31
PA Section |
Statute |
Probate Court Proceedings |
Indigent Costs |
Old law |
PA 90-31 |
§ 1 |
17-183(c) |
Commitment of mentally ill person under emergency certificate |
Counsel fees for hearing to contest |
Funds appropriated to Judicial Dept. |
Probate Court Administration Fund, rates established by probate court administrator |
§ 2 |
45-17a |
Probate court proceedings including service of process |
Costs, fees, and expenses |
Same as above |
Probate Court Administration Fund |
§ 3 |
45-45(e) |
Removal or reinstatement of parent as guardian and appointment of guardian |
Counsel for child and respondents |
Rates established and paid by funds appropriated to the Judicial Dept. |
Rates established by the Probate Court Administrator and paid by the Probate Court Administration Fund |
§ 4 |
45-61e |
Petition filed for (1) termination of parental rights of child committed to commissioner of children and youth services, (2) petition to terminate parental rights, and (3) hearing on petition to terminate parental rights |
Attorney's fees for petitioner |
Same as above |
Rates set by Probate Court Administrator And paid from Probate Court Administration Fund |
§ 5 |
45-61f |
Termination of parental rights hearing |
Attorney's fees for counsel who represent respondent parent or child |
Same as above |
Same as above |
§ 5 |
45-61f |
Termination of parental rights hearing |
Cost of examination of child or parent by doctor |
Funds appropriated to the Judicial Dept. |
Probate Court Administration Fund |
§ 6 |
45-70c(b) |
Proceeding for appointment of a conservator |
Counsel fees for respondent |
Rates set by and paid from funds appropriated to the Judicial Dept. |
Rates set by the probate court administrator and paid from the Probate Court Administration Fund |
Table 2: -Continued-
PA Section |
Statute |
Probate Court Proceedings |
Indigent Costs |
Old law |
PA 90-31 |
§ 7 |
45-325 |
Petition for the appointment of a guardian |
Counsel fees for adult who is the subject of a petition |
Same as above |
Same as above |
§ 8 |
46b-172a |
Paternity claim by putative father of child born out of wedlock |
Guardian ad litem of child and for the mother if she is a minor |
Funds appropriated to the Judicial Dept. |
Probate Court Administration Fund |
1996 LEGISLATION
In 1996, the legislature amended the law to make the Judicial Department responsible for indigent costs, only if, and only to the extent, the legislature appropriated money from the General Fund to the Judicial Branch for this purpose.
SOURCE OF EXPENDITURES FOR INDIGENT COSTS IN PROBATE COURT SINCE FY 78/79
Table 3 shows the amount of indigent funds paid from the General Fund and the Probate Court Administration Fund from FY 78/79 through FY 06/07. This information was compiled by Vinnie Russo, Legislative Liaison for the Office of the Probate Court Administrator.
Table 3: SOURCE OF EXPENDITURES FOR INDIGENT EXPENSES IN PROBATE COURT 1978 TO 2007
Budget Year |
Expended Amount | ||
General Fund |
Probate Administration Fund |
Total | |
78-79 |
$49,731 |
$0 |
$49,731 |
79-80 |
$48,000 |
$0 |
$48,000 |
80-81 |
$215,000 |
$0 |
$215,000 |
81-82 |
$129,675 |
$0 |
$129,675 |
82-83 |
$154,864 |
$0 |
$154,864 |
83-84 |
$205,406 |
$0 |
$205,406 |
84-85 |
$252,052 |
$0 |
$252,052 |
85-86 |
$253,606 |
$0 |
$253,606 |
86-87 |
$298,608 |
$0 |
$298,608 |
Table 3: -Continued-
Budget Year |
Expended Amount | ||
General Fund |
Probate Administration Fund |
Total | |
87-88 |
$192,929 |
$0 |
$192,929 |
88-89 |
$225,932 |
$0 |
$225,932 |
89-90 |
$0 |
$71,840 |
$71,840 |
90-91 |
$0 |
$264,710 |
$264,710 |
91-92 |
$0 |
$385,000 |
$385,000 |
92-93 |
$0 |
$480,000 |
$480,000 |
93-94 |
$0 |
$586,821 |
$586,821 |
94-95 |
$0 |
$742,136 |
$742,136 |
95-96 |
$0 |
$872,517 |
$872,517 |
96-97 |
$0 |
$994,661 |
$994,661 |
97-98 |
$0 |
$1,028,223 |
$1,028,223 |
98-99 |
$500,000 |
$641,541 |
$1,141,541 |
99-00 |
$500,000 |
$742,829 |
$1,242,829 |
00-01 |
$500,000 |
$814,509 |
$1,314,509 |
01-02 |
$400,000 |
$1,054,393 |
$1,454,393 |
02-03 |
$0 |
$1,501,237 |
$1,501,237 |
03-04 |
$0 |
$1,794,552 |
$1,794,552 |
04-05 |
$0 |
$2,740,847 |
$2,740,847 |
05-06 |
$25,000 |
$3,364,490 |
$3,389,490 |
06-07 |
$0 |
$3,719,341 |
$3,719,341 |
Total |
$3,950,803 |
$21,799,647 |
$25,750,450 |
GC:ts