Topic:
CHILD HEALTH; MEDICAID; MEDICAL CARE; PREGNANCY; SOCIAL SERVICES; STATISTICAL INFORMATION;
Location:
INSURANCE - HEALTH; MEDICAL CARE;

OLR Research Report


June 30, 2008

 

2008-R-0387

HIGH-RISK PREGNANCY CARE AND BIRTH OUTCOME TRENDS

By: Saul Spigel, Chief Analyst

Robin K. Cohen, Principal Analyst

You asked (1) for an explanation of how the Department of Social Services (DSS) provided for the care of women with high-risk pregnancies after April 1, 2008 when managed care organizations dropped out of the HUSKY program and (2) how DSS plans to care for women with such pregnancies when a new managed care system begins on July 1, 2008. You also wanted data showing birth outcome trends over the past 25 years.

SUMMARY

When Governor Rell terminated the contracts of four managed care organizations (MCOs) serving the HUSKY Program on April 1, 2008 recipients were given the choice of obtaining service through two of the MCOs' networks (with the MCO acting purely in an administrator, not insurer, capacity) or moving to fee-for-service (FFS) Medicaid and choosing a provider.

Women who did not switch to FFS continued to receive case management through the remaining MCOs. Of the pregnant women who switched to FFS from the other two MCOs, the Department of Social Services (DSS) referred 14 it determined posed high-risk pregnancies to five Healthy Start contractors. Healthy Start is a prenatal outreach program that operates in 17 communities whose rates of infant mortality

and low-birthweight babies are disproportionately high. It is jointly funded and managed by DSS and the Public Health Department (DPH). DSS added approximately $29,000 to each contractor's budget for taking these new clients.

Beginning July 1, DSS will resume offering the HUSKY program through full-risk MCOs; HUSKY recipients will not be served under the FFS model. Healthy Start contractors will have the option of referring case management responsibility for high-risk pregnant women to the MCO the woman chooses.

The percentage of low-birthweight babies (under 2,500 grams) has fluctuated over the 25-year period we examined (1981 to 2006); the trend over the past 10 years has been upward. The percentage has been consistently high among mothers under age 20, minority and Hispanic mothers of all ages, and urban residents, while it fluctuates in suburban and rural areas.

The total number and percent of premature births has nearly doubled over the past 25 years. The total has nearly tripled for mothers over age 20, while it has declined for mothers under age 20. Higher percentages of prematurity are also linked to race and ethnicity.

Fetal deaths have decreased over the past 25 years overall, for both age groups, and among racial groups. They have risen among the Hispanic population, probably because of that group's growth.

HANDLING HIGH-RISK PREGNANCIES SINCE APRIL 1

Exiting MCOs and New HUSKY Structure as of April 1

On April 1, the health care landscape changed when Governor Rell terminated the four contracts between DSS and HUSKY MCOs. As of that date, two of the MCOs, HealthNet and Preferred One, stopped providing any services while the other two (Blue Cross Family Plan and CHNCT) continued to maintain a HUSKY role. HUSKY members from the terminated MCOs were given the option either to enroll with Blue Cross or CHNCT or to be placed in traditional FFS Medicaid. Members who failed to choose a plan defaulted into FFS.

Blue Cross and CHNCT act essentially like administrative service organizations (ASOs) and handle only HUSKY's administrative functions. They bill DSS for all medical services their network providers perform based on the department's fee schedules and in turn pay the providers. In return, DSS has paid them a much-reduced monthly fee per HUSKY member.

Treatment of High-Risk Pregnant Women

DSS's goal, outlined in a March 14, 2008 advisory letter, was to minimize the number of pregnant women in traditional FFS Medicaid (presumably, because the MCOs would have better provider networks). It directed its HUSKY enrollment broker, ACS, Inc., to call pregnant women who had previously received or were receiving case management from HealthNet or Preferred One and had either chosen, or defaulted into, FFS to see if they wanted to switch to Blue Cross or CHNCT.

HealthNet and Preferred One identified approximately 150 pregnant women who switched to FFS. Six were already labeled as at high-risk by one of the plans, and DSS determined another eight were at high risk because the MCO had been providing them with either case management or disease management services. DDS decided to refer the women to Healthy Start because its responsibilities include case management and health education. Table 1 provides a breakdown of the 14 referrals, by Healthy Start contractor.

Table 1: High-Risk Pregnancy Referrals to Healthy Start Contractors

Healthy Start Contractor

Referrals

UCFS

1

Staywell

5

New Haven Health Department

4

Bridgeport

2

Hartford Health Department

2

Blue Cross and CHNCT continued to provide case management under their ASO arrangements to women with high-risk pregnancies who they had previously served and those who moved from the other two MCOs, according to Rose Ciarcia, the HUSKY program's manager. We do not know how many such women they are serving. The administrative services fee DSS pays the plans includes services such as case management, call center customer services, and utilization management.

Funding

According to Ciarcia, DSS added roughly $29,000 to each Healthy Start contract (which included Maternal and Child Health funds it had just received and a cost-of-living adjustment) as compensation for the referrals.

PLANS FOR JULY 1

On July 1, DSS will again offer full-risk health insurance under the HUSKY program through MCOs. Three MCOs have been chosen to serve HUSKY clients—Aetna Better Health, Americhoice, and CHNCT. At that time, HUSKY recipients will no longer be able to be served under FFS Medicaid.

The MCOs will provide case management services, and pregnant women enrolled in Healthy Start will receive their medical services through them. Ciarcia reports that MCOs' standard practice is to contact new members and do a risk assessment either by phone or through a questionnaire they send with the member handbook and card. They offer case management to members they identify as high risk. A member who is receiving case management through Healthy Start can continue to do so or can choose to have the MCO take over case management. Ciarcia expects that the 14 women transferred to Healthy Start will have delivered by the time the transition to the new MCOs is completed.

BIRTH OUTCOME TRENDS

The following tables show trends from 1981 to 2006 for low-birthweight babies (Table 2), low-birthweight for selected towns (Table 3), premature deliveries (Table 4), and fetal deaths (Table 5). The data are broken down by race and ethnicity, mothers' age (under or over 20), and, in Table 3, by residence.

Table 2 shows that the percentage of low-birthweight babies (< 2,500 grams) fluctuated over the 25-years from 7.3% in 1981, to 6.5% in 1986, and then upward in the next 20 years, reaching 8.2% in 2006. The rate of low-birthweight is highest among African-American women, always over 12%. It is also high among mothers under age 20—over 10% until 2001 when it dropped to 8.7% before rising again to 9.7% in 2006. The percentage is considerably higher among African-American and Hispanic mothers under age 20.

We selected three types of towns to show in Table 3. One is those with the highest percentages of low-birthweight babies for all racial groups over the entire period. These are urban and larger suburban communities with high percentages of minority and Hispanic mothers (Bridgeport, East Hartford, Hartford, New Haven, New Britain, and Waterbury). The second type are suburban and rural towns where more than 8% of births in 1981 were low-birthweight (Avon, Rocky Hill, Winchester); the third type are similar towns whose percentage grew to that level over the 25 years (Berlin, Clinton, Killingly).

Because they have fewer total births, the percentage of low-birthweight babies in the rural and suburban towns fluctuated considerably. The percentage of low-birthweight babies in the urbanized areas was consistently high, especially among minority and ethnic mothers.

The data show a steep increase in the number and percent of premature births (<37 weeks gestation) between 1986 and 1991. The total number and percent of premature births has nearly doubled over the past 25 years. The total has nearly tripled for mothers over age 20, but it has declined among younger mothers. The data also show significantly higher percentages of prematurity among mothers under age 20 and African-American mothers of all ages.

Fetal deaths have decreased significantly over the past 25 years overall and for both age groups and among racial groups. Fetal deaths have risen among the Hispanic population, probably because of that group's growth.

All data are derived from DPH's Annual Registration Report.

Table 2: Low Birthweight, By Mother's Race and Ethnicity and Age, 1981 to 2006

   

1981

 

1986

 

Total Births

Low Birthweight1

Very Low Birthweight2

Total Births

Low Birthweight

Very Low Birthweight

   

#

%

#

%

 

#

%

#

%

All Races

39999

2902

7.3

532

1.3

44881

2936

6.5

561

1.2

nonwhite3

5619

745

13.3

174

3.1

6444

788

12.2

190

2.9

white, nonhispanic

Not reported

       

Not reported

       

black, nonhispanic

nr

       

nr

       

other, nonhispanic4

nr

       

nr

       

Hispanic

nr

       

nr

       

Mother <20

                   

All races

4384

445

10.1

101

2.3

3960

414

10.5

74

1.9

nonwhite

1321

204

15.4

50

3.8

1329

188

14.1

35

2.6

white, nonhispanic

                   

black, nonhispanic

                   

other, nonhispanic

                   

Hispanic

                   

Mother 20>

                   

All races

35615

2457

6.9

431

1.2

40921

2522

6.2

487

1.2

nonwhite

4298

541

12.6

124

2.9

5115

600

11.7

155

3

white, nonhispanic

                   

black, nonhispanic

                   

other, nonhispanic

                   

Hispanic

                   

   

1991

 

1996

 

Total Births

Low Birthweight

Very Low Birthweight

Total Births

Low Birthweight

Very Low Birthweight

   

#

%

#

%

 

#

%

#

%

All Races

48542

3543

6.9

779

1.4

44555

3199

7.3

667

1.5

nonwhite3

                   

white, nonhispanic

33284

1773

5.3

317

0.1

29779

1750

5.9

327

1.1

black, nonhispanic

5409

778

14.4

200

3.7

4769

626

13.1

161

3.4

other, nonhispanic4

1037

17

1.6

95

0.9

1420

121

4.3

21

1.5

Hispanic

5363

440

8.2

76

1.4

5621

493

8.8

105

1.9

Mother <20

                   

All races

3395

394

1.6

87

2.6

3655

386

10.6

86

2.4

nonwhite

                   

white, nonhispanic

1382

78

5.6

30

2.2

1288

87

6.8

18

1.4

black, nonhispanic

996

130

13.1

43

4.3

894

140

15.7

35

3.9

other, nonhispanic

45

4

8.9

-

-

83

9

10.8

2

2.4

Hispanic

1303

140

10.7

22

1.7

1262

130

10.3

27

2.1

Mother 20>

                   

All races

45147

3149

7

692

1.5

40900

2813

6.9

581

1.4

nonwhite

                   

white, nonhispanic

31902

1695

5.3

287

0.9

28491

1663

5.8

309

1.1

black, nonhispanic

4413

648

14.7

157

3.6

3875

486

12.5

96

2.5

other, nonhispanic

992

95

9.6

13

1.3

1337

112

8.4

19

1.4

Hispanic

4060

300

7.4

54

1.3

4359

363

8.3

78

1.8

   

2001

 

2006

 

Total Births

Low Birthweight

Very Low Birthweight

Total Births

Low Birthweight

Very Low Birthweight

   

#

%

#

%

 

#

%

#

%

All Races

42,659

3139

7.4

649

1.5

41606

3376

8.2

685

1.7

nonwhite3

                   

white, nonhispanic

27,891

1764

6.3

325

1.2

25029

1747

7.0

289

1.2

black, nonhispanic

4,835

601

12.4

179

3.7

5033

637

12.7

206

4.1

other, nonhispanic4

2,158

160

7.4

20

<1

2726

241

8.8

46

1.7

Hispanic

6,883

559

8.1

114

1.7

8456

748

8.8

141

1.7

Mother <20

                   

All races

3,144

272

8.7

60

1.9

2900

282

9.7

56

1.9

nonwhite

                   

white, nonhispanic

1026

70

6.8

14

1.4

803

46

5.7

9

1.1

black, nonhispanic

726

72

10

24

3.3

706

94

13.3

28

4

other, nonhispanic

73

7

10

3

4.1

68

8

11.8

2

2.9

Hispanic

1259

109

8.7

19

1.5

1310

133

10.2

16

1.2

Mother 20>

                   

All races

39515

2867

7.3

589

1.5

38706

3094

8

629

1.6

nonwhite

                   

white, nonhispanic

26865

1694

6.3

311

1.2

24406

1701

7

280

1.1

black, nonhispanic

4109

529

12.9

155

3.8

4327

543

12.5

178

4.1

other, nonhispanic

2085

153

7.3

17

<1

2658

233

8.8

44

1.7

Hispanic

5624

450

8

95

1.7

7146

615

8.6

125

1.7

1. <2,500 grams or 5.5 lbs (includes VLB)

4. includes unknown, nonhispanic

2. <1,500 grams

3. not defined

 

Table 3: Birthweight, By Mother's Race and Ethnicity, Age, and Town Of Residence, 1981 to 2006

   

1981

 

1986

 

Total Births

Low Birthweight1

Very Low Birthweight2

Total Births

Low Birthweight

Very Low Birthweight

Residence

     

nr

       

nr

 

Avon

                   

all races

117

12

10.3

   

129

6

4.7

   

Nonwhite2

3

-

-

   

3

-

-

   

Berlin

                   

all races

156

12

7.7

   

186

9

4.8

   

nonwhite

3

-

-

   

3

-

-

   

Bridgeport

                   

all races

2642

245

9.3

   

2808

233

8.3

   

nonwhite

812

113

13.9

   

946

107

11.3

   

Clinton

                   

all races

163

8

4.9

   

189

16

8.5

   

nonwhite

3

-

-

   

2

-

-

   

E. Hartford

                   

all races

631

59

9.4

   

659

47

7.1

   

nonwhite

92

15

16.3

   

63

12

19

   

Hartford

                   

all races

2746

332

12.1

   

2988

357

11.9

   

nonwhite

1246

191

15.3

   

1344

196

14.6

   

Killingly

                   

all races

199

7

3.5

   

237

17

7.2

   

nonwhite

3

-

-

   

7

2

28.6

   

New Britain

                   

all races

1048

84

8

   

1097

78

7.1

   

nonwhite

105

13

12.4

   

134

29

21.6

   

New Haven

                   

all races

2086

215

10.3

   

2166

224

10.3

   

nonwhite

1027

147

14.3

   

1043

147

14.1

   

Putnam

                   

all races

131

14

10.7

   

128

9

7

   

nonwhite

2

-

-

   

4

-

-

   

Rocky Hill

                   

all races

163

16

10

   

190

5

2.6

   

nonwhite

8

4

50

   

9

-

-

   

Waterbury

                   

all races

1464

119

8.1

   

1736

154

8.9

   

nonwhite

271

40

14.8

   

337

56

16.6

   

Winchester

                   

all races

164

16

9.8

   

181

12

6.6

   

nonwhite

3

-

-

   

5

-

-

   

   

1991

 

1996

 

Total Births

Low Birthweight

Very Low Birthweight

Total Births

Low Birthweight

Very Low Birthweight

Residence

                   

Avon

                   

all races

155

6

3.9

1

-

172

-

-

7

4.1

Nonwhite1

8

1

-

-

-

11

-

-

-

-

Berlin

                   

all races

164

5

3

1

<1

194

11

5.7

1

<1

nonwhite

3

-

-

-

-

9

2

22

-

-

Bridgeport

                   

all races

2935

283

9.7

66

2.3

2250

217

9.7

47

2.1

nonwhite

2035

230

11.3

54

2.7

1680

179

10.7

38

2.3

Clinton

                   

all races

188

18

9.6

4

2.1

151

4

2.6

-

-

nonwhite

5

-

-

-

-

8

-

-

-

-

E. Hartford

                   

all races

675

59

8.7

7

1

609

66

10.9

16

2.6

nonwhite

178

17

9.6

2

1.1

279

29

10.4

8

2.9

Hartford

                   

all races

3131

405

13

86

2.8

2264

274

12.1

64

2.8

nonwhite

2524

342

13.5

68

2.7

1992

250

12.6

58

2.9

Killingly

                   

all races

247

11

4.5

-

-

224

21

9.4

2

<1

nonwhite

6

-

-

-

-

10

1

10

-

-

New Britain

                   

all races

1201

100

8.3

21

1.7

1020

98

9.6

16

1.6

nonwhite

448

47

10.5

15

3.1

481

53

11

8

1.7

New Haven

                   

all races

2379

248

10.4

50

2.1

1805

188

10.4

44

2.4

nonwhite

1340

157

11.7

29

2.2

1289

150

11,6

40

3.1

Putnam

                   

all races

122

10

8.2

3

2.5

92

4

4.3

-

-

nonwhite

3

-

-

-

-

3

-

-

-

-

Rocky Hill

                   

all races

245

26

10.6

3

1.2

195

14

7.2

2

1

nonwhite

29

8

28

1

3.4

27

1

3.7

2

7.4

Waterbury

                   

all races

2106

174

8.3

36

1.7

1700

161

9.5

30

1.8

nonwhite

834

93

11.2

18

2.2

795

77

9.8

12

1.5

Winchester

                   

all races

172

12

7

2

1.2

142

11

7.7

1

0.7

nonwhite

6

1

1.2

-

-

7

-

-

1

14.2

   

2001

 

2006

 

Total Births

Low Birthweight

Very Low Birthweight

Total Births

Low Birthweight

Very Low Birthweight

Residence

                   

Avon

                   

all races

167

6

3.6

1

<1

154

9

5.8

2

1.3

Nonwhite2

4

2

50

1

25

27

-

-

2

7.4

Berlin

                   

all races

175

14

8

2

1.1

164

14

8.5

1

<1

nonwhite

11

1

9.1

-

-

22

1

4.5

-

-

Bridgeport

                   

all races

2268

211

9.3

49

2.2

2485

253

10.3

52

2.1

nonwhite

1814

180

9.9

45

2.5

2017

262

13

48

2.4

Clinton

                   

all races

184

20

10.9

7

3.8

142

15

10.6

1

<1

nonwhite

13

2

15.4

2

15.4

11

1

9.1

-

-

E. Hartford

                   

all races

669

57

8.5

11

1.6

701

76

10.9

21

3

nonwhite

425

39

9.6

10

2.4

496

55

11

21

4.2

Hartford

                   

all races

2224

253

11.4

57

2.6

2238

293

13.1

83

3.7

nonwhite

1993

239

12

48

2.4

2038

272

13.3

79

3.9

Killingly

                   

all races

214

19

8.9

1

<1

214

23

10.7

5

2.3

nonwhite

17

-

-

-

-

9

-

-

-

-

New Britain

                   

all races

1012

75

7.4

23

2.3

1087

107

9.8

23

2.1

nonwhite

641

55

8.6

19

3

716

17

2.4

81

11.3

New Haven

                   

all races

1930

206

10.7

52

2.7

2127

204

9.6

42

2

nonwhite

1481

167

11.3

42

2.8

1674

172

10.3

40

2.4

Putnam

                   

all races

122

9

7.4

2

<1

101

6

5.9

2

2

nonwhite

12

2

16.6

2

16.6

8

-

-

-

-

Rocky Hill

                   

all races

171

9

5.3

-

-

195

21

10.8

7

3.6

nonwhite

36

4

11.1

-

-

78

15

19.2

6

7.7

Waterbury

                   

all races

1636

147

9

28

1.7

1659

180

10.9

30

1.8

nonwhite

882

89

10

13

1.5

1007

122

12.1

24

2.4

Winchester

                   

all races

143

14

9.8

2

1.3

118

15

12.7

1

<1

nonwhite

6

-

-

-

-

15

-

-

5

33

1. From 1991 to 2006, includes black, other nonhispanic, and Hispanic; excludes unknown ethnicities, consequently may sum to less than total for all races

Table 4: Prematurity1, by Mother's Race and Ethnicity and Age, 1981 to 2006

 

1981

1986

1991

1996

2001

2006

 

#

%2

#

%

#

%

#

%

#

%

#

%

Race

                       

All Races3

2113

5.3

2292

5.1

4135

9.3

4039

9.6

4071

9.5

4067

9.9

nonwhite

520

9.3

559

8.7

               

white, nonhispanic

       

2380

7.6

2422

8.4

2480

8.9

2304

9.2

black, nonhispanic

       

799

16.5

620

13.7

628

13

646

13

other, nonhispanic

       

111

10.8

149

10.5

193

13.6

237

8.6

Hispanic

       

546

11.7

611

11.7

716

10.4

879

10.5

Mother <20

                       

All Races

210

4.8

309

7.8

480

13.2

438

12

299

9.5

295

10.2

nonwhite

126

9.5

146

11

               

white, nonhispanic

       

133

10.3

126

9.8

85

8.3

57

7.1

black, nonhispanic

       

158

17.2

136

15.2

66

9.1

77

11

other, nonhispanic

       

5

12.5

6

7.2

6

8.2

6

8.8

Hispanic

       

154

13.6

151

12

135

10.7

155

11.8

Mother 20>

                       

All Races

1303

3.7

1983

4.8

3655

8.8

3601

8.8

3985

10.1

3742

9.6

nonwhite

394

9.2

413

8.1

               

white, nonhispanic

       

2247

7.5

2296

8.1

2456

9.1

2247

7.9

black, nonhispanic

       

641

16.3

484

12.5

607

14.8

569

13.1

other, nonhispanic

       

106

11.5

143

10.7

192

9.2

231

8.7

Hispanic

       

440

12.5

460

10.6

676

12

724

10.1

1. <37 weeks gestation

2. % of all births for group

3. Total includes births of unknown ethnicity, consequently components below sum to less than total % of births where gestational age is known

Table 5: Fetal Death, by Mother's Race and Ethnicity and Age,

1981 to 2006

 

1981

1986

1991

1996

2001

2006

All Races

326

304

337

284

200

232

nonwhite

51

83

       

white, nonhispanic

   

238

217

144

152

black, nonhispanic

   

84

54

46

66

other, nonhispanic

   

7

9

9

11

Hispanic

   

39

45

33

50

Mother <20

           

All Races

36

49

38

32

23

21

nonwhite

15

20

       

white, nonhispanic

   

23

17

12

7

black, nonhispanic

   

10

13

10

13

other, nonhispanic

   

1

1

1

-

Hispanic

   

6

11

10

6

Mother >20

           

All Races

290

255

299

252

177

211

nonwhite

36

63

       

white, nonhispanic

   

215

200

132

145

black, nonhispanic

   

74

41

36

53

other, nonhispanic

   

6

8

8

11

Hispanic

   

33

34

23

44

SS:ts