OLR Bill Analysis

sHB 6664

AN ACT CONCERNING REVISIONS TO VARIOUS STATUTES CONCERNING THE CRIMINAL JUSTICE SYSTEM.

SUMMARY:

This bill:

1. provides that juvenile prosecutors employed by the Division of Criminal Justice on July 1, 2009 are considered appointed by the Criminal Justice Commission with the powers and duties of assistant state's attorneys;

2. requires the court, instead of the prosecutor, to provide a transcript of certain sentencing hearings to the Board of Pardons and Paroles;

3. limits access to state and local police reports and witness statements by the Division of Public Defender Services unless authorized by a prosecutorial official;

4. expands the circumstances under which a person on probation is guilty of failure to appear;

5. lowers the maximum possible penalty for violations of first-degree sexual assault against a victim under age 10;

6. allows a court to suspend the mandatory minimum sentence for first-degree sexual assault if at the time of the offense, the offender was under age 18 or his or her mental capacity was significantly impaired;

7. exempts from the law on witness sequestration certain adult witnesses in child assault, sexual assault, or abuse cases;

8. potentially increases the penalty for jurors who fail to respond to a jury summons;

9. expands the crime of forgery to punish someone who falsely makes, completes, or alters a written instrument by signing his or her own name to it to falsely and fraudulently represent that he or she has authority to sign the document; and

10. makes confidential youthful offender records available to law enforcement and prosecutorial officials conducting legitimate criminal investigations.

EFFECTIVE DATE: October 1, 2009 except the provisions on juvenile prosecutors are effective July 1, 2009 and the provision on sentencing transcripts is effective upon passage.

§§ 1-9 — JUVENILE PROSECUTORS

The bill provides that juvenile prosecutors employed by the Division of Criminal Justice on July 1, 2009 (1) are deemed to have been appointed by the Criminal Justice Commission, (2) have and exercise all the powers and perform all the duties of an assistant state's attorney, (3) may act in any judicial district and in connection with any matter regardless of the judicial district where the offense took place, and (4) may be assigned to act in any judicial district at any time on designation by the chief state's attorney. The bill makes numerous conforming changes.

The bill also provides that beginning July 1, 2009, any “prosecutorial official” assigned to handle juvenile matters in the criminal session of the Superior Court will have been appointed by the Criminal Justice Commission.

Apparently the term “prosecutorial official” refers to the chief state's attorney, each deputy chief state's attorney, and each state's attorney, assistant state's attorney and deputy assistant state's attorney (CGS §§ 51-278a & 51-287a).

§ 10—SENTENCING TRANSCRIPTS

By law, prosecutors must request transcripts of certain sentencing hearings for delivery to the Board of Pardons and Paroles. The bill requires the prosecutor's request to be on the record and makes the court, instead of the prosecutor, responsible for delivering the transcript to the board. The affected sentencing hearings are those at which a defendant is sentenced to a definite, non-suspended sentence of more than two years imprisonment.

§ 11 — ACCESS TO CERTAIN INFORMATION

Current law gives state and local criminal justice agencies access to all state and local police reports, presentence investigations and reports, psychological and medical reports, criminal records, incarceration and parole records, and court records and transcripts in the statewide criminal justice information technology system whether such records and documents normally exist in electronic or hard copy forms. The bill limits access to state and local police reports and witness statements by the Division of Public Defender Services unless authorized by a prosecutorial official.

§§ 12-13 — FAILURE TO APPEAR

The bill expands the circumstances under which a person on probation for a felony conviction or a misdemeanor or motor vehicle violation is guilty of failure to appear. Under current law, the person is guilty if he or she misses a legally called probation violation hearing. Under the bill, the person is guilty if he or she is misses any legally called court hearing related to a probation violation.

Failure to appear at a hearing on a felony violation is a class D felony punishable by up to five years in prison, a $ 5,000 fine or both. Failure to appear for a hearing on a misdemeanor or motor vehicle violation is a class A misdemeanor punishable by up to one year in prison, a fine of up to $ 2,000, or both.

§§ 14-15 — SEXUAL ASSAULT

The bill lowers the maximum possible penalty for violations of first-degree sexual assault against a victim under age 10. Under current law, a person is guilty of first-degree sexual assault if he or she (1) has sexual intercourse with a child under age 13 and (2) is more than two years older than the victim. If the victim is under age 10, the penalty is a class A felony punishable by 10 to 25 years in prison, up to a $ 20,000 fine, or both. The penalty carries a mandatory minimum sentence of 10 years.

The bill separates this crime into two distinct crimes: one involving victims between age 10 and 13 and the second involving victims under age 10. The former carries the same penalty, including the same mandatory minimum as in current law. The latter is a class B felony punishable by up to 20 years in prison, up to a $ 15,000 fine, or both. The penalty still carries the 10-year mandatory minimum sentence.

The bill allows the court to suspend the mandatory minimum sentence if at the time of the offense, the offender was under age 18 or his or her mental capacity was significantly impaired.

§ 16 — SEQUESTERING A WITNESS

By law, if the state or defense asks, the court must sequester a witness during portions of a trial when they are not testifying. The bill exempts from this requirement criminal cases involving the assault, sexual assault, or abuse of a child age 12 or younger if the witness is an adult (1) the child knows, (2) with whom the child feels comfortable, and (3) who has the court's permission to sit near the child as he or she testifies.

§ 17 — FAILURE TO APPEAR FOR JURY DUTY

The bill subjects jurors who fail to appear for jury duty to a civil penalty in an amount that the Superior Court judges must establish. Under current law, they are guilty of an infraction.

§ 18 — FORGERY

The bill expands the crime of forgery to punish someone who falsely makes, completes, or alters a written instrument by signing his or her own name to it to falsely and fraudulently represent that he or she has authority to sign the document.

By law, a person commits forgery by falsely making, completing, or altering a written instrument with intent to defraud, deceive, or injure someone or possessing a forged written instrument. The penalty ranges from a class B misdemeanor to a class C felony depending on the type of document being forged.

§ 19 — YOUTHFUL OFFENDER RECORDS

The bill makes confidential youthful offender records available to law enforcement and prosecutorial officials conducting legitimate criminal investigations. By law, records of youthful offenders are confidential unless they involve certain crimes. Current law allows disclosure of confidential records:

1. between agencies and individuals directly providing services to the youth, including law enforcement, state and federal prosecutors, school and court officials, the Division of Criminal Justices, the Court Support Services Division, and a crime victim advocate;

2. to the youth and the youth's parents or guardian until the youth reach age 18 or is emancipated;

3. to the youth's attorney if they are relevant to a proceeding; and

4. to Board of Pardons and Paroles and corrections employees who need them to perform their duties when (a) the offender is adjudged a youthful offender and sentenced to prison or convicted of a crime and (b) the records are relevant to a risk and needs assessment during incarceration or determining suitability for release or a pardon or supervision and treatment needs on parole or other release.

By law, records disclosed under these provisions cannot be further disclosed.

BACKGROUND

State Wide Criminal Justice Criminal Justice Information System

The law requires the Criminal Justice Information System Governing Board to design and implement a comprehensive, state-wide information technology system to facilitate the sharing of information between all state agencies, departments, boards, and commissions having any cognizance over matters relating to law enforcement and criminal justice, and organized local police departments and law enforcement officials (CGS § 54-142s).

COMMITTEE ACTION

Judiciary Committee

Joint Favorable Substitute

Yea

42

Nay

0