Topic:
CRIME VICTIMS; CRIMINAL STATISTICS; CRIME; ARREST RECORDS; MINORITIES; PERSISTENT OFFENDERS; SENTENCING;
Location:
CRIMINAL STATISTICS;

OLR Research Report


January 18, 2008

 

2008-R-0008

CRIME RATE AND CONVICTION RATES BROKEN DOWN BY RACE

By: George Coppolo, Chief Attorney

Kevin McCarthy, Principal Analyst

You asked for Connecticut's crime rate broken down by the race of the offender and victim, and the racial breakdown of the offenders who have been convicted for a third strike in California?

SUMMARY

Offender Rate

Based on information contained in the Uniform Crime Reports from 2000 to 2004, and in the U. S. Census Bureau's Population Estimates Program (1/4/08), we were able to prepare estimates on the arrest rates for certain crimes broken down by race. This data indicates that the arrest rate for blacks for murder was 10 to 15 times as high as for whites, five to six times the rate for whites for sexual assault, eight to nine times as high for robbery, four to five times as high for aggravated assault, and between two to three times as high for burglary.

Incarceration Rates

We did not find any incarceration rates for Connecticut prepared by any Connecticut agency or organization. But we were able to find relevant information for 2005 prepared by an organization called the Sentencing Project, a Washington D. C. based national non-profit organization involved in research and advocacy on criminal justice policy issues, and for 2006 from the U. S. Department of Justice (U. S. Department of Justice Office of Justice Programs Bureau of Justice Statistics Bulletin Prisoners in 2006 December 2007, NCJ 219416. )

According to the Sentencing Project's website, the rate of incarceration for white Connecticut residents in 2005 was 211 per 100,000 people; for black residents it was 2,532 per 100,000. The Sentencing Project reports that the national incarceration rate for whites in 2005 was 412 per 100,000, and the rate for blacks was 2,290 per 100,000 people. http: //www. sentencingproject. org/Admin/Documents/publications/rd_stateratesofincbyraceandethnicity. pdf

Also according to the Sentencing Project's web site, in seven states (Iowa, Vermont, New Jersey, Connecticut, Wisconsin, North Dakota, and South Dakota) the black to white incarceration ratio is greater than 10 to one. The national rate is 5. 6 to one and the ratios range from 13. 6 to one for Iowa to just under two to one in Hawaii. Connecticut's rate is about 12 to 1. The Project concluded that Connecticut's black to white ratio is so high because Connecticut's rate of white incarceration is very low whereas its rate for black incarceration is a little above the national average.

According to Justice Department data, in 2006 black men were being incarcerated at a rate of 3,042 per 100,000. This data also indicated that

1. about one in every 33 black men was a sentenced prisoner and the rate for white men was about one in every 205, for Hispanic men about one in every 79; and

2. black men represented the largest proportion of sentenced male inmates at yearend 2006 (38%); white men made up 34%; and Hispanic men, 21%.

Victimization Rates

We were not able to find any Connecticut crime victimization rates. But a Bureau of Justice Statistics report based on a national survey of households concluded that in 2005 the national victimization rate for crimes committed against the person for whites age 12 and older was 20. 9 per 100,000 people, while the victimization rate for blacks was 28. 7 per 100,000.

Blacks were victims of an estimated 805,000 non-fatal violent crimes and of about 8,000 homicides in 2005. While blacks accounted for 13% of the U. S. population in 2005, they were victims in 15% of all non-fatal violent crimes and nearly half of all homicides. These findings are based on data from the Bureau of Justice Statistics' National Crime

Victimization Survey (NCVS) and the Federal Bureau of Investigation's (FBI) Uniform Crime Reporting Program (UCR), Supplementary Homicide Reports.

According to Department of Justice's analysis of national crime statistics, blacks have generally had a serious violent crime victimization rate of about twice that of whites for the past two decades. During 2005, for example, the black victimization rate for serious violent crime was 13. 6 compared to the rate for whites of 6. 5. (Serious violent crimes include homicide, rape, robbery, and aggravated assault. )

California

In 1994, California approved a major change in its criminal sentencing laws. This change has commonly been referred to as the “Three Strikes and You're Out” law. This law imposed longer prison sentences for certain repeat offenders, as well as instituted other changes. Under this law, if a person has one previous serious or violent felony conviction, the sentence for any new felony conviction (not just a serious or violent felony) is twice the term otherwise required by law. Offenders sentenced under this provision are often referred to as “second strikers. ” If a person has two or more previous serious or violent felony convictions, the sentence for any new felony conviction (not just a serious or violent felony) is life imprisonment with the minimum term of 25 years. Offenders convicted under this provision are frequently referred to as “third strikers” ( A Primer: Three Strikes- The Impact After More Than a Decade, prepared by Brian Brown and Greg Jalivette of the California legislature's Legislative Analyst's Office). We have enclosed a copy of this report, which may be accessed on the web at http: //www. threestrikes. org/3_strikes_102005. pdf

According to a 2004 report from the Justice Policy Institute, African Americans make up 6. 5% of California's population, nearly 30 % of the prison population, 36 % of second strikers, and 45% of third strikers (Racial Divide An Examination of the Impact of California's Three Strike Law on African-Americans and Latinos, by Scott Ehlers, Vincent Schiraldi, and Eric Lotke).

ARREST DATA FROM CONNECTICUT

The following arrest data was taken from the annual reports of the Uniform Crime Reporting Program, State of Connecticut Department of Public Safety, Division of State Police, Crime Analysis Unit. The arrest rates were derived from applying this data to population data from the U. S. Census Bureau's Population Estimates Program (January 4, 2008).

Number of Arrestees by Race 200 – 2004 in Connecticut

Table 1: Murder Arrestees by Race in Connecticut

2000 to 2004

Year

White

Black

Other

Asian

Indian

Unknown

Total

2004

35

45

0

1

0

35

117

2003

44

34

 

2

0

28

108

2002

33

37

 

1

0

26

97

2001

50

54

0

Not listed

Not listed

1

138

2000

52

38

0

-

-

24

114

Table 2: Robbery Arrestees by Race in Connecticut

2000-2004

Year

White

Black

Asian

Indian

Unknown

Total

2004

839

884

6

1

6

1,736

2003

782

790

7

1

5

1585

2002

920

761

0

4

2

1687

     

Other*

     

2001

801

754

5

-

-

1,560

2000

633

678

5-

-

-

1,316

*For 2001 and 2000 the statistics were reported as White, Black, and “Other Race”

Table 3: Rape Arrestees by Race in Connecticut

2000-2004

Year

White

Black

Asian

Indian

Unknown

Total

2004

203

100

2

0

1

306

2003

175

106

3

0

1

285

2002

217

118

0

0

0

335

     

Other*

     

2001

206

109

0

-

-

315

2000

170

129

7

-

-

306

*For 2001 and 2000 the statistics were reported as White, Black, and “Other Race”

Table 4: Aggravated Assault Arrestees by Race in Connecticut

2000-2004

Year

White

Black

Asian

Indian

Unknown

Total

2004

2,676

1,657

28

2

16

4,379

2003

2884

1,083

47

6

9

3,967

2002

2,892

1550

31

10

9

4492

     

Other*

     

2001

3,127

1,759

45

   

4,931

2000

3,191

1,661

43

-

-

4,895

*For 2001 and 2000 the statistics were reported as White, Black, and “Other Race”

Table 5: -Burglary Arrestees by Race in Connecticut

2000-2004

Year

White

Black

Asian

Indian

Unknown

Total

2004

2,263

665

15

0

28

2,971

2003

2,600

704

17

1

10

2,912

2002

2,462

688

30

1

8

3,189

     

Other*

     

2001

2,276

699

18

   

2,993

2000

2,170

685

15

-

-

2,870

*For 2001 and 2000 the statistics were reported as White, Black, and “Other Race”

Table 6: Larceny Arrestees by Race in Connecticut

2000-2004

Year

White

Black

Asian

Indian

Unknown

Total

2004

10,235

3,894

134

20

79

14,362

2003

10,221

4,100

141

33

68

14,563

2002

11,226

4,573

161

21

60

16,041

     

Other*

     

2001

11,057

4,828

184

-

-

16,069

2000

10,658

4,379

164

-

-

15,201

*For 2001 and 2000 the statistics were reported as White, Black, and “Other Race”

Table 7: Motor Vehicle Theft Arrestees by Race in Connecticut

2000-2004

Year

White

Black

Asian

Indian

Unknown

Total

2004

632

386

9

2

12

1,041

2003

745

495

9

3

7

1259

2002

915

570

4

1

5

1,495

     

Other*

     

2001

706

588

10

-

-

1,304

2000

711

580

5

-

-

1,296

*For 2001 and 2000 the statistics were reported as White, Black, and “Other Race”

Table 8: Arson Arrestees by Race in Connecticut

2000-2004

Year

White

Black

Asian

Indian

Unknown

Total

2004

133

30

2

0

0

165

2003

143

29

0

1

0

173

2002

159

32

1

0

1

193

     

Other*

     

2001

146

31

3

-

-

180

2000

178

34

0

-

-

212

*For 2001 and 2000 the statistics were reported as White, Black, and “Other Race”

Arrest Rates by Race in Connecticut 2000 - 2004

Table 9: Rape Arrest Rates per 100,000 People*

 

2000

2001

2002

2003

2004

White

7

6

7

7

6

Black

30

31

34

31

37

Other

2

1

0

0

2

Rounded up to the nearest whole number

Table 10: Robbery Arrest Rates per 100,000 People*

 

2000

2001

2002

2003

2004

White

29

27

31

27

21

Black

264

233

221

216

192

Other

9

9

4

3

3

Rounded up to the nearest whole number

Table 11: Aggravated Assault Arrest Rate per 100,000*

 

2000

2001

2002

2003

2004

White

91

98

98

105

107

Black

496

319

450

503

472

Other

33

42

32

27

26

Rounded up to the nearest whole number

Table 12: Burglary Rate per 100,000*

 

2000

2001

2002

2003

2004

White

74

77

83

88

76

Black

205

206

200

201

189

Other

11

12

25

17

25

Rounded up to the nearest whole number

INCARCERATION RATES

We took the following two incarceration rate tables for each state directly from the Sentencing Project's web site.

Table 13: Prison & Jail Incarceration Rates, 2005

Rate of Incarceration per 100,000 Population

State

White

Black

Hispanic

Alabama

542

1916

-

Alaska

500

2163

380

Arizona

590

3294

1075

Arkansas

478

1846

288

California

460

2992

782

Colorado

525

3491

1042

Connecticut

211

2532

1401

Delaware

396

2517

683

District of Columbia

56

1065

267

Florida

588

2615

382

Georgia

623

2068

576

Hawaii

453

851

185

Idaho

675

2869

1654

Illinois

223

2020

415

Indiana

463

2526

579

Iowa

309

4200

764

Kansas

443

3096

-

Kentucky

561

2793

757

Louisiana

523

2452

244

Maine

262

1992

-

Maryland

288

1579

-

Massachusetts

201

1635

1229

Michigan

412

2262

397

Minnesota

212

1937

-

Mississippi

503

1742

611

Missouri

487

2556

587

Montana

433

3569

846

NATIONAL

412

2290

742

Nebraska

290

2418

739

Nevada

627

2916

621

New Hampshire

289

2666

1063

New Jersey

190

2352

630

New York

174

1627

778

North Carolina

320

1727

-

North Dakota

267

2683

848

Ohio

344

2196

613

Oklahoma

740

3252

832

Oregon

502

2930

573

Pennsylvania

305

2792

1714

Rhode Island

191

1838

631

South Carolina

415

1856

476

South Dakota

470

4710

-

Tennessee

487

2006

561

Texas

667

3162

830

Utah

392

3588

838

Vermont

304

3797

-

Virginia

396

2331

487

Washington

393

2522

527

West Virginia

392

2188

211

Wisconsin

415

4416

-

Source: The Sentencing Project Uneven Justice: State Rates of Incarceration by Race and Ethnicity by Marc Mauer and Ryan S. King, July 2007

*Incarceration rates based on data from the Bureau of Justice Statistics, Prison and Jail Inmates at Midyear 2005. New Mexico and Wyoming have been excluded due to lack of data on race and ethnicity.

Table 14: Prison & Jail Incarceration Rates, 2005, by Black-to-White Ratio Rate of Incarceration per 100,000 Population

State

White

Black

B-to-W Ratio

District of Columbia

56

1065

19. 0

Iowa

309

4200

13. 6

Vermont

304

3797

12. 5

New Jersey

190

2352

12. 4

Connecticut

211

2532

12. 0

Wisconsin

415

4416

10. 6

North Dakota

267

2683

10. 0

South Dakota

470

4710

10. 0

Rhode Island

191

1838

9. 6

New York

174

1627

</