February 24, 2006 |
2006-R-0166 | |
TASER USE BY CONNECTICUT POLICE DEPARTMENTS | ||
| ||
By: Veronica Rose, Principal Analyst Adam Wolkoff, Legislative Fellow | ||
You asked how many Connecticut police departments are using tasers and what policies govern their use.
SUMMARY
A taser is an electronic defense weapon. At least 71 Connecticut police departments, including the State Police, use tasers, and at least another 27 have evaluated or are currently evaluating them, according to Taser International data. Most of the departments own fewer than 50 tasers. Waterbury, with 190, has the most. The State Police has five. The State Capitol Police evaluated the weapons but was denied funding to buy them.
The 13 departments we randomly contacted by telephone or email all indicated that they have written taser policies. The seven policies we describe in this report vary widely in scope and level of detail. Typically, they cover authorized uses and users; training, certification, and recertification requirements; use and operational standards; and post use procedures, including documentation requirements and treatment of persons subjected to taser shocks.
Some of the more comprehensive policies cover other issues, including safety considerations, weapon inspection, and investigations of taser use.
All of the policies we reviewed (1) require taser users to be trained and certified, (2) set standards for taser use, (3) require officers to document and report taser use; and (4) set procedures that officers must follow when they use a taser.
Only Danbury's policy allows suspension of an officer's authority to carry tasers for just cause. Only the State Police policy specifies where an officer should aim the taser (below head and neck), although Danbury's policy references its use-of-force policy for specific guidelines on application. And only the State Police policy requires a supervisory review of every case in which an officer deploys a taser.
We have attached for your review policies from Cromwell, Danbury, and the State Police.
TASERS
The taser is an “electro muscular disruption weapon” designed to incapacitate without causing serious physical injury or death. It is a type of electronic defense weapon. Several companies manufacture electronic defense weapons, including stun guns, but Taser International is the sole manufacturer of tasers. The company, located in Arizona, produces various models, including the M26 and X26, which it sells to law enforcement entities, and the M18 models, which the general public can buy. The M26 model costs $400; the X26 costs $800. Both operate in essentially the same way, but the X26 is newer, smaller, and lighter than the M26 model.
TASER USE BY CONNECTICUT POLICE DEPARTMENTS
Under CGS §§ 53-206 and 29-38, it is illegal for anyone other than a peace officer to carry electronic defense weapons upon his person or in a vehicle. (RB 105, currently before the Public Safety Committee, would apply the ban to sales, without exceptions.) At least 70 local Connecticut police departments and the State Police are using tasers (see Attachment 1). They include large departments such as Bloomfield, East Hartford, Greenwich, Waterbury, and West Hartford, and small departments such as Canton, Easton, and Granby. According to Taser International data, the Connecticut department with the largest number of tasers is Waterbury (190), followed by Meriden with 64 and Norwalk with 59. The State Police has five.
At least another 27 departments are either evaluating tasers or did so in the past few years. They include the State Capitol Police, which was denied funding to buy them; large departments such as Bridgeport, Hartford, and Stamford; and small departments such as Prospect and Putnam (see Attachment 2).
TASER ASSIGNMENTS TO OFFICERS
Anecdotal information suggests that departments that use tasers want to arm all of their sworn officers with them. Currently however, they are unable to do so because they do not have enough tasers. The most common practice appears to be for departments to assign the tasers to patrol officers, who are most likely to encounter situations requiring their use. Danbury assigns one taser to the training officer and two to the Special Investigations Division. It requires all patrol officers to carry the taser and encourages other officers to carry them. It also requires officers to carry tasers when in marked squad cars and encourages officers in unmarked cars to carry them as well. The State Police assigns its tasers to officers in the tactical unit.
TASER POLICIES
Six departments provided us with copies of their policies. These are Bloomfield, Cromwell, Danbury, Seymour, West Hartford, and the State Police. East Hartford summarized the major provisions of its policy in an email to our office.
The policies from these seven departments uniformly address training and certification; taser use (sometimes called deployment); and procedures officers must follow after deploying their tasers, including the kind of aid they must provide to people subjected to taser shocks and the kinds of reports they must complete. We have summarized the major provisions of these seven policies below.
Training and Certification Requirements
All seven departments require officers to be trained and certified before they are authorized to use tasers. They also require that users and instructors be recertified periodically (usually every year for users and every two years for instructors). In most departments, training for initial certification is four hours. West Hartford requires eight hours. Taser training is in addition to required firearms and use-of-force training for police officers.
Taser International offers both user and instructor training and recertification courses. The most common practice is for police officers certified as instructors by Taser International to train other officers. Danbury and West Hartford, for example, have three officers certified as training instructors.
Taser Use Protocols
Use-of-force policies provide general guidelines for police officers to follow in determining what level of force to apply in any given situation. Six of the seven departments have separate use-of-force policies for tasers. Cromwell's policy is incorporated in its general use-of-force policy.
Two departments, Cromwell and Seymour, place taser use on the same level as OC spray on the use-of-force continuum. The former authorizes officers to deploy tasers at their discretion in situations such as the following:
1. when a person exhibits violent or potentially violent behavior that threatens the safety of others and attempts to subdue by conventional means have been or appear too unlikely to be effective;
2. when it is unsafe to get within contact range of the subject;
3. when the use of deadly force is justified and an opportunity exists to use the taser, deploy the taser if available; and
4. when a prisoner's behavior warrants classification in any of the above.
State Police policy authorizes the use of tasers when the use of less lethal options would help effect an arrest, restore order, or reduce the risk of more serious injury. Under the policy, an officer is justified in using the taser in the following situations, for example:
1. to restore or maintain order during prison disturbances;
2. to restore or maintain order during very violent civil disturbances where innocent people may be rescued or where police are confronted with a level of force likely to cause serious physical injury such as Molotov cocktails being thrown or dangerous weapons or instruments are being used;
3. to subdue vicious animals; or
4. to safely resolve a situation or incident, where the authorizing person deems its use necessary to resolve.
Danbury's policy lists taser use as an intermediate force option on the use-of-force continuum. It specifies that intermediate force options are “designed for use against subjects exhibiting behavior that qualifies as active resistance or aggression, assault or threat of assault or life threatening assault, or assaults likely to cause great bodily harm.”
Bloomfield requires officers to use tasers in accordance with the department's use-of-force policy. West Hartford requires officers to use tasers in accordance with department policy, using “only that level of force reasonably necessary to control or otherwise subdue violent or potentially violent individuals.”
Post Use Protocols
Dealing with Persons Subjected to Taser Shock. Tasers fire two metal barbs attached to wires. The charge incapacitates by causing the muscles to contract. The probes can penetrate the skin up to one-quarter inches, depending on a variety of factors (e.g., distance from the subject).
All the policies include standards for removing probes that penetrate an individual's skin. In Seymour and West Hartford, medical personnel remove probes embedded in sensitive areas, and police officers remove probes in all other areas. Medical personnel remove the probes under the Bloomfield, Danbury, and State Police policies, except that the police officer may remove them under the Danbury policy in “exigent circumstances.” Cromwell's policy appears to give discretion to the officer. The policy states that “if the Taser barbs become imbedded . . . in the subject, the supervisor will have discretion as to having the subject transported to the hospital by ambulance or by the arresting officer. If there is no skin penetration, the subject does not have to be taken for medical treatment.” (East Hartford did not provide information on probe removal.)
As with probe removal, the medical aid provisions vary. Under the State Police policy, the officer must render immediate first aid to a subject he strikes with a taser, if necessary, and then transport the subject to a medical facility. Similarly, Danbury requires medical personnel to evaluate anyone an officer strikes with a taser. Cromwell requires medical treatment for subjects, but only in cases where the probe penetrates the skin. Seymour gives officers discretion to summon medical aid, as necessary, except if the probe penetrates a sensitive area, the policy requires emergency medical services personnel to render medical assistance. (East Hartford did not provide information on probe removal.)
Documentation of Taser Use. All seven departments require officers who deploy tasers to report the use, usually to a supervisor, on a taser incident form or other department form. In addition to the official taser form, state police officers must complete a written report, detailing their observations, any commands they gave before deploying the taser, approximate distance from the subject, description of the subject and his clothing, point of aim and impact, and a description of the subject's reaction. Anecdotal information suggests that similar information is included in the reports that the other six departments complete.
All seven policies require officers to take and include in their reports photographs of the areas of the body hit by a taser probe.
Review of Reports and Investigations. Both the State Police and West Hartford Police Department require departmental review of taser reports. Under the West Hartford policy, the assistant chief reviews individual reports, and the training lieutenant does an annual review. The State Police requires a supervisor to review all instances of taser use and determine if the weapon was used in compliance with department policy. Danbury requires the review when the officer deploys the taser under exceptional circumstances. “Exceptional circumstances” are those “where a person sustains a substantial injury, where an officer strikes a target inconsistent with training guidelines, where injuries are inconsistent with the normal performance of the device, and/or where improper use of the taser is shown or suspected.”
Bloomfield, Cromwell, and Seymour's policies do not address review and investigation.
Miscellaneous
Weapon Inspection. All the policies, except the State Police policy, require users to conduct some kind of test or inspection of the weapon before they go into the field to ensure that it is working. The most common practice is for officers to do the check at the beginning of each shift.
Carrying Tasers. Four of the policies specify how officers must carry the weapons. Both Danbury and West Hartford require officers to carry the taser in an approved holster on the support side of the body opposite the officer's handgun. This is the only common element. Seymour requires the weapon to be carried with an air cartridge loaded into the deployment port. Bloomfield requires that officers load batteries into the device but no cartridge in the deployment port. And West Hartford requires batteries in the device along with a cartridge loaded in the deployment port.
Taser Misuse. Only Danbury's policy allows suspension of an officer's authority to carry tasers for just cause. The policy does not define just cause.
Attachment 1: Connecticut Police Departments Using Tasers
Department |
Department |
Department | |||
1 |
Ansonia* |
25 |
Hamden* |
49 |
South Windsor* |
2 |
Avon |
26 |
Manchester |
50 |
Southbury |
3 |
Bethel |
27 |
Meriden |
51 |
Southern Connecticut State University |
4 |
Bloomfield* |
28 |
Middlebury |
52 |
Stratford |
5 |
Bristol |
29 |
Middletown |
53 |
Suffield |
6 |
Brookfield |
30 |
Milford |
54 |
Torrington |
7 |
Canton |
31 |
Monroe |
55 |
Trumbull |
8 |
Cheshire |
32 |
New Britain |
56 |
UConn |
9 |
Clinton |
33 |
New Canaan |
57 |
Vernon |
10 |
Cromwell* |
34 |
New Haven |
58 |
Wallingford |
11 |
Danbury* |
35 |
New London* |
59 |
Waterbury |
12 |
Darien |
36 |
New Milford |
60 |
Waterford |
13 |
East Hartford* |
37 |
Newington |
61 |
West Hartford* |
14 |
East Lyme |
38 |
Newtown |
62 |
West Haven |
15 |
East Windsor |
39 |
North Branford |
63 |
Weston |
16 |
Easton |
40 |
North Haven |
64 |
Wethersfield* |
17 |
Enfield |
41 |
Norwalk |
65 |
Wilton |
18 |
Farmington |
42 |
Norwich* |
66 |
Windsor Locks |
19 |
Glastonbury* |
43 |
Orange |
67 |
Windsor |
20 |
Granby |
44 |
Plymouth |
68 |
Wolcott |
21 |
Greenwich* |
45 |
Portland |
69 |
Woodbridge |
22 |
Groton City |
46 |
Redding |
70 |
State Police* |
23 |
Groton |
47 |
Seymour* |
71 |
Mashantucket Pequot Tribe Police |
24 |
Guilford |
48 |
Shelton |
* Departments Randomly Selected for Policies
Source: Taser International data, provided by Jay Kehoe, Eastern Regional Manager for Taser International
Attachment 2: Departments That Have Evaluated or are Evaluating Tasers
Department |
Department | ||
1 |
Berlin |
15 |
Ridgefield |
2 |
Bridgeport |
16 |
Southbury |
3 |
Coventry |
17 |
Southington |
4 |
East Haddam |
18 |
Stamford |
5 |
Eastern Connecticut State |
19 |
Stonington |
6 |
Fairfield |
20 |
Trumbull |
7 |
Hartford |
21 |
Warren |
8 |
Madison |
22 |
Watertown |
9 |
Montville |
23 |
Wethersfield |
10 |
Naugatuck |
24 |
Western Connecticut |
11 |
New Fairfield |
25 |
Woodbury |
12 |
Plainfield |
26 |
Yale University |
13 |
Prospect |
27 |
State Capitol Police |
14 |
Putnam |
Source: Taser International data, provided by Jay Kehoe, Eastern Regional Manager for Taser International
Attachment 3: Highlights of Select Police Department Taser Policies*
Dept. |
No. of Tasers Owned by Dept. |
Officers to Whom Tasers are Assigned |
Training/ And Initial Certificat-ion |
Training Instructors |
Recertification Requirement |
Weapon Inspection |
Probe Removal/ Medical Attention |
Documentation of Taser Use |
Review/Investigation |
Bloomfield |
5 |
Supervisors and patrol officers |
Yes |
Department members certified by Taser International as instructors |
Every two years |
Readiness test at beginning of each shift and annually by taser certified instructor |
Officers provide medical aid, except if the probes penetrate the subject's skin, they must transport him to hospital |
Incident Report |
Policy does not address |
Cromwell |
15 |
All sworn officers and detectives All patrol vehicles; |
4 hours |
Department members certified by Taser International as instructors |
Annual (1 hour) |
When officer inspects vehicle |
Supervisor has discretion as to who removes the barb |
Use of Force Supplemental Report |
Policy does not address |
Danbury |
34 |
Patrol officers and officers working extra-duty jobs in marked squad cars must carry tasers; non-patrol officers and officers working extra duty jobs in unmarked cars are encouraged to carry them. |
4 hours |
Department members certified by Taser International as instructors |
Annual (2 hours plus requalification with the taser) |
Spark test at beginning of each shift |
Medical personnel remove probes except officer might do so under exigent circumstances; Medical personnel must evaluate subject |
Incident Report and Response to Resistance form |
Chain-of-command review of all cases where weapon deployed in exceptional circumstances; supervisors may review other deployments |
East Hartford |
28 (plans to add another 20 in next few weeks) |
Patrol officers |
Yes |
Department members certified by Taser International as instructors |
Annual |
Readiness check at beginning of each shift |
Officers provide first aid at scene or arrange for subject to be transported |
Department report |
Records maintained for annual reports |
Seymour |
Not reported |
Not reported (authorized for use by all officers who have completed taser training) |
Yes |
Department members certified by Taser International as instructors |
Policy silent |
Readiness test when issued |
Officer, with exception, renders first aid and removes probe |
Taser Use Report |
Policy does not address |
W. Hartford |
24 tasers |
Most assigned to patrol officers and officers on traffic duty |
8 hours |
Department members certified by Taser International as instructors |
Annual |
Spark check at beginning of each shift |
Officer removes probe, unless embedded in sensitive areas |
Department's incident report and Taser Use Report |
Assistant chief reviews each report; training lieutenant produces annual report for review and analysis |
State Police |
5 tasers |
Officers in the Tactical Unit |
4.5 hours |
Department members certified by Taser International as instructors |
Annual |
Function test before every tactical call |
Medics or medically trained personnel remove probes that penetrate the skin; Officers render immediate first aid then transport subject to medical facility. |
Use of Force report required |
Supervisor investigate all uses |
*Information is based on a review of department policies and department responses to specific questions about their policies or both. East Harford's is based solely on information the department provided in an email response to our office.